The Evolution of Insect Resistance to Bt Crops
June 14, 2013 3 Comments
A group of scientists at the University of Arizona have this week published a paper in Nature Biotechnology on the evolution of resistance in insect pests populations to insecticidal proteins from Bacillus thuringiensis (Bt) that are produced by transgenic crops. Resistance is defined as the phenotype of an individual that gives the individual the ability to survive on a transgenic insecticidal plant from egg to adult and provide viable offspring. The team analysed field and laboratory data from seventy-seven studies of thirteen pest species in eighteen countries across five continents. Entomologist Bruce Tabashnik and colleagues found well documented cases of field-evolved resistance to Bt crops in five major pests as of 2010. 60% of these cases occurred in the U.S.A, where approximately half of the world’s Bt crop acreage is planted. In some cases, resistance to Bt evolved within as little as two to three years, whilst in other cases Bt crops have remained effective for more than 15 years. The research team aimed to better understand how quickly insect populations are evolving resistance to Bt crops and how this is occurring.
Approximately 1 billion acres of Bt crops have been planted in the past 16 years and many kinds of transgenic crops are now available for commercial use, including herbicide tolerant crops, insect resistant crops, and drought and stress tolerant crops. Bt crops that have been developed to date include maize, cotton, rice and soyabeans. The factors found by the research team that favour efficacy of Bt crops are in line with what would be expected based on evolutionary theory. The researchers reported in their paper that factors that appear to delay Bt resistance in insect populations include recessive inheritance of resistance, low initial frequency of resistance alleles and abundant refuges of non-Bt host plants. The researchers have suggested how this type of data can be used to provide practical advice on insect resistance management. For example, if data collected suggests that the pest’s resistance is likely to be recessive the risk of rapid resistance evolution is low. However when the resistance risk is higher farmers should take more stringent measures to delay resistance, such as requiring larger refuges. The concept behind providing refuge habitat is to reduce the selection pressure so that resistant insects have less of an advantage in comparison to non-resistant insects. This management strategy requires that a host plant other than the Bt crop is grown nearby as a refuge for the pests. The larger the refuge the smaller the proportion of the population exposed to selection.
Resistance in insects is a serious problem which can lead to increased insecticide use and can compromise the development of new novel pest management products. For some pests such as the Colorado Potato Beetle (Leptinotarsa decimlineata) and the Diamondback moth (Plutella xylostella) resistance is now so widespread that few effective management options remain. Further research into resistance management of transgenic insecticidal Bt crops is particularly important because Bt crops are an effective and targeted method of pest management that reduces spraying of insecticides and associated environmental risk.
Tabashnik, B., Brévault, T., & Carrière, Y. (2013). Insect resistance to Bt crops: lessons from the first billion acres Nature Biotechnology, 31 (6), 510-521 DOI: 10.1038/nbt.2597